Todos os relatórios
The Werewolves of Miller's Hollow relatórios
#12607: "Shutdown communication during night"
Sobre o que é este relatório?
O que aconteceu ? Por favor escolha abaixo
Sugestão: Na minha opinião, o que sugiro a seguir poderia melhorar muito a implementação do jogo
Descrição detalhada
• Por favor, explique sua sugestão precisamente e de forma concisa, de forma que fique o mais fácil possível, entender o que você quer dizer.
During night time, players should not be able to send messages using the chat, as talking during the night is not permitted I think in the game.• Qual navegador você está usando?
Google Chrome v74
Histórico do relatório
29 mai 2019 14:55 • tilalilalou • Esta sugestão ainda não foi analisada pelos desenvolvedores:
Fortune teller should not be able to tell something before dawn, if she is still alive.
Players try to guess who is werewolf or not based on who writes or don't at night, which is not in the spirit of the game I think.
Players try to guess who is werewolf or not based on who writes or don't at night, which is not in the spirit of the game I think.
29 mai 2019 20:39 • Pantoufle • Esta sugestão ainda não foi analisada pelos desenvolvedores:
I've played another online adaptation of the game who was approved by the original creators. Chat is no permitted at all during the night, only the wolves can chat between themselves when they have to choose who to eat (no one can read what they're saying at that time).
I've read the rules from the card game. They say that everyone has to sleep, eyes closed. When the Narrator calls any role during the night, the called character(s) can open their eyes, rise their head and and point people but have to stay silent.
From both these sources, it is evident that chat should not be allowed at all during night if you want to stay close to the original Loups-garous de Thiercelieux game.
At the time, the seer for example can immediately tells their information during the night when they have a good chance to die at the morning, which is not something that has been allowed anywhere I've played the game.
I've read the rules from the card game. They say that everyone has to sleep, eyes closed. When the Narrator calls any role during the night, the called character(s) can open their eyes, rise their head and and point people but have to stay silent.
From both these sources, it is evident that chat should not be allowed at all during night if you want to stay close to the original Loups-garous de Thiercelieux game.
At the time, the seer for example can immediately tells their information during the night when they have a good chance to die at the morning, which is not something that has been allowed anywhere I've played the game.
2 jun 2019 8:09 • -HKS- • Esta sugestão ainda não foi analisada pelos desenvolvedores:
I am with Pantoufle. No talking should be allowed at night.
2 jun 2019 21:49 • marion_scr • Esta sugestão ainda não foi analisada pelos desenvolvedores:
Exemple of cheating with night taliking :
Table #52580182
THe little said what she saw at night just before dying. She shouldn't have talked because she should have been dead in the morning
Table #52580182
THe little said what she saw at night just before dying. She shouldn't have talked because she should have been dead in the morning
8 jun 2019 18:52 • Entoine_Fk • Esta sugestão ainda não foi analisada pelos desenvolvedores:
There is a bug where a werewolf and the hunter are the last player !!!
So the werewolf eat the hunter who MUST shoot back, but CAN'T shoot the last player!
So the werewolf eat the hunter who MUST shoot back, but CAN'T shoot the last player!
9 jun 2019 1:57 • J-Effe IV • Esta sugestão ainda não foi analisada pelos desenvolvedores:
+1. At the very least, please allow the creator of the table to disable it.
10 jun 2019 17:54 • xxerox • Esta sugestão ainda não foi analisada pelos desenvolvedores:
Its general in EVERY SINGLE WW/MAFIA GAME AROUND THE WORLD that during the night no one to be able to speak.
16 jun 2019 8:09 • Didgeridoof • Esta sugestão ainda não foi analisada pelos desenvolvedores:
I agree, shutdown communication at night. I have ADHD and have issues with impulse control, and got so excited to play werewolf today as the little girl that I accidentally said the werewolf's name at night, before I died, which the other players rightfully denounced as cheating. I didn't mean to cheat, but I remembered and regret breaking the real life rule once I said it. I would appreciate it if the interface didn't allow for this at all.
5 jul 2019 23:08 • ClimateChangeIsReal • Esta sugestão ainda não foi analisada pelos desenvolvedores:
I agree with this with the following restrictions:
(1) Dead players should still be able to talk amongst themselves at night, and
(2) there should be a 5-10 second "twilight" after lynching where people can talk before night (to allow people to finish last-second thoughts)
(1) Dead players should still be able to talk amongst themselves at night, and
(2) there should be a 5-10 second "twilight" after lynching where people can talk before night (to allow people to finish last-second thoughts)
13 ago 2019 15:10 • Serilo • Esta sugestão ainda não foi analisada pelos desenvolvedores:
This is incorrectly filed as suggestion - it is a bug.
17 ago 2019 7:02 • 101waystomeeturmaker • Esta sugestão ainda não foi analisada pelos desenvolvedores:
i suggest creating an additional option during selection for the setting "chaos" where night talking is permitted without option selected then no discussion at night is possible..
19 ago 2019 0:48 • BronzeKnight • Esta sugestão ainda não foi analisada pelos desenvolvedores:
This bug should become high priority. It ruins so many good games.
26 ago 2019 17:13 • JCase16 • Esta sugestão ainda não foi analisada pelos desenvolvedores:
I agree. I ruined a game without thinking about it. Please disable chat during the night
7 out 2019 4:42 • ShawnStar • Esta sugestão ainda não foi analisada pelos desenvolvedores:
Talking at night leads to table fighting and drama nearly every game.
22 abr 2020 10:21 • Marcooooo • Esta sugestão ainda não foi analisada pelos desenvolvedores:
I talk at night during werewolves games and I don't see the problem. But I think some players gave me red thumbs for that, and now I can't play with them forever on the whole BGA website.
You should just make it an option during the setup of the game, "talk at night : disabled" so there is no more conflicts about it.
You should just make it an option during the setup of the game, "talk at night : disabled" so there is no more conflicts about it.
11 mai 2020 14:35 • barium2000 • Esta sugestão ainda não foi analisada pelos desenvolvedores:
I disagree with this suggestion. The guidelines for BGA developers are aimed at REPLICATING, as much as possible, a real board game experience, and not creating a videogame. Therefore, we should ask:
Can people speak at night during the "real" boardgame? YES (as there is no switch that allow mute real people...).
Do people usually speak at night during the "real boardgame"? NO, as they adhere to some "honor code".
Therefore, it is the decision of players who they play with. In my personal experience, people usually adhere to that honor code of not revealing relevant information during night (althought they may say non-relevant stuff)
My suggestion to tackle this issue (in decreasing order of preference) would be:
1- Allow the table admin to state the "house rules" in a special (e.g., highlighted) message at the beginning of the game, and vote down users who do not adhere to them.
2- (less preferred) Enable this option as an optional switch by the table admin.
Can people speak at night during the "real" boardgame? YES (as there is no switch that allow mute real people...).
Do people usually speak at night during the "real boardgame"? NO, as they adhere to some "honor code".
Therefore, it is the decision of players who they play with. In my personal experience, people usually adhere to that honor code of not revealing relevant information during night (althought they may say non-relevant stuff)
My suggestion to tackle this issue (in decreasing order of preference) would be:
1- Allow the table admin to state the "house rules" in a special (e.g., highlighted) message at the beginning of the game, and vote down users who do not adhere to them.
2- (less preferred) Enable this option as an optional switch by the table admin.
22 mai 2020 13:43 • Alius1 • Esta sugestão ainda não foi analisada pelos desenvolvedores:
This should be optional! So a setting to turn on or off. I would like to downvote it in the current style
22 mai 2020 23:21 • Alius1 • Esta sugestão ainda não foi analisada pelos desenvolvedores:
double entry
23 mai 2020 11:11 • aghagh • Esta sugestão ainda não foi analisada pelos desenvolvedores:
A comment on some of the latest comments. I think Implemented games here at BGA should allow just what's allowed in the game. They are not Vassal modules. In physical games a player may ruin a game in many ways : punching on the board, flipping players' cards, taking more tokens than he's supposed to, etc. Would we want that ? Would we really leave it up to players to respect not only game rules but a minimum of social manners as well? I think it's the wrong approach. Playing online has some drawbacks as compared to physical games, but it also has some advantages. Let's make use of them.
Online chat for this game should be cut at night (except for the dead chat, of course). Optionally, as Pantoufle mentions, an open chat just for werewolves could also be considered (if so, it should not be indicated who is currently writing on top of the chat window, as that would give way the werewolves).
Online chat for this game should be cut at night (except for the dead chat, of course). Optionally, as Pantoufle mentions, an open chat just for werewolves could also be considered (if so, it should not be indicated who is currently writing on top of the chat window, as that would give way the werewolves).
24 mai 2020 8:28 • kllll • Esta sugestão ainda não foi analisada pelos desenvolvedores:
there is a bug with the vote.
First bug,
(a)ww is killed by barber and (a)ww can still vote.
Second bug,
hunter shoot twice after die.
First bug,
(a)ww is killed by barber and (a)ww can still vote.
Second bug,
hunter shoot twice after die.
9 jun 2020 7:26 • Tracypeich • Esta sugestão ainda não foi analisada pelos desenvolvedores:
Yo no he dejado nada a medias
13 jun 2020 22:56 • Maximaths • Esta sugestão ainda não foi analisada pelos desenvolvedores:
Showing your cursor should be prohibited as well.
1 jul 2020 17:28 • Jeb_101 • Esta sugestão ainda não foi analisada pelos desenvolvedores:
You shouldn't be able to do anything exepct play. For example, If you are ww, you should only be able to eat villagers at nighttime.
2 jul 2020 11:29 • mala34ii • Esta sugestão ainda não foi analisada pelos desenvolvedores:
Je suis désolé je suis agent sécurité ya un moment j'étais très occupé
17 jul 2020 15:00 • Darknighter • Esta sugestão ainda não foi analisada pelos desenvolvedores:
The graphics are all over the place which is making it difficult to understand the game..... And little graphical changes can do wonders with the game
19 ago 2020 2:04 • I_call_yellow • Esta sugestão ainda não foi analisada pelos desenvolvedores:
i agree. especially if there is cheating. people say roles and share urls so they converse on discord and vote off ft every night and That is cheating, slong with sny talking as stated above!,,,,
27 out 2020 16:09 • grognasse gâtinal • Esta sugestão ainda não foi analisada pelos desenvolvedores:
je ne sais pas
27 out 2020 16:09 • grognasse gâtinal • Esta sugestão ainda não foi analisada pelos desenvolvedores:
je ne sais pas
11 nov 2020 10:49 • grognasse gâtinal • Esta sugestão ainda não foi analisada pelos desenvolvedores:
idont
11 nov 2020 10:50 • grognasse gâtinal • Esta sugestão ainda não foi analisada pelos desenvolvedores:
a
11 nov 2020 10:50 • grognasse gâtinal • Esta sugestão ainda não foi analisada pelos desenvolvedores:
i dont no
8 dez 2020 8:11 • docter • Esta sugestão ainda não foi analisada pelos desenvolvedores:
no host,but the table still here
19 jan 2021 3:04 • docter • Esta sugestão ainda não foi analisada pelos desenvolvedores:
when the game no cupido and thief didn't swap,there will be cupido bug sometimes.
cupido bug=no cupido but have cupido timer
cupido bug=no cupido but have cupido timer
2 ago 2021 18:09 • pogthebrave • Esta sugestão ainda não foi analisada pelos desenvolvedores:
I think it could be a choice like it is currently used as a HR
31 out 2021 20:58 • Kells96 • Esta sugestão ainda não foi analisada pelos desenvolvedores:
If Thief does not swap in the game there Will be appaer a cupid bug even when cupid is not in the game
30 mai 2022 4:28 • BillyBullet • Esta sugestão ainda não foi analisada pelos desenvolvedores:
I can't report anything, always the error message. what is the tech support link??? how can they want someone to be a paying user with a site with bad technical support?
7 out 2022 21:48 • RaxoGG99 • Esta sugestão ainda não foi analisada pelos desenvolvedores:
Yeah Jack
1 fev 2025 4:54 • KonaStar • Esta sugestão ainda não foi analisada pelos desenvolvedores:
Honestly I disagree with this. Lots of people like to joke and play around I understand giving up information but people should be better than that. I think this is a personal thing and would ruin some of the fun charm to the game if we couldn’t talk at all.
Adicione alguma coisa para este relatório
Por favor, adicione aqui qualquer coisa que pareça relevante para a reprodução deste bug ou o entendimento de sua sugestão:
- Outro ID de mesa / ID de jogada
- Carregar em F5 resolveu o problema?
- O problema aparece várias vezes? Sempre? Imprevisivelmente?
- Se tiver uma captura de ecrã/tela deste problema (boa prática), pode usar Imgur.com para carregá-la e copiar/colar o endereço aqui.
