Todos os relatórios
Troyes relatórios
#17879: "End Gaming Scoring for Cathedral Not Properly Calculated"
Sobre o que é este relatório?
O que aconteceu ? Por favor escolha abaixo
Bug de visualização: alguma informação de jogo mostrada estava errada (sem consequencia importante no jogo)
Descrição detalhada
• Por favor descreva o problema de visualização. Se tiver uma captura de ecrã/tela deste problema (boa prática), pode usar Imgur.com para carregá-la e copiar/colar o endereço aqui.
End game scoring for Cathedral not properly calculated.
imgur.com/tRVthXy
See here that blue has cubes in row 1 & row 2, but not row 3. Should have -2 points at the end of the game.
Green only has a cube in row one. Should have -4 points at end of game.
imgur.com/xooo0Q3
Final scoring - blue has -0 and green has -3
***
That being said, did not affect enjoyment of game. Overall 5 stars. Great work!!! =)• Qual navegador você está usando?
Google Chrome v81
Histórico do relatório
10 jun 2020 8:00 • Alebaster • Bug não foi reproduzido pela equipa de desenvolvimento ainda:
I have no involvement in this game. But having wondered about a similar situation it's important to remember that you score points for every cube in the cathedral. Therefore, if the event card comes out that removes the top most cube you could end up with a situation where you scored a cube, then had it removed. You would have scored the cube, then had a negative for no longer being in that row. That would make the score -3, instead of -4. I'm not saying that happened. But it is a possibility.
13 jun 2020 17:35 • zoid4 • Bug não foi reproduzido pela equipa de desenvolvimento ainda:
Cubes coloring seems wrong. As the Beige player, I was attributed the scoring of grey/neutral cubes (at + 6) and there is no Beige Cube. I cant remember if I have put any cube in Cathedral but Cube player-assoctation seems to be messed up (a Dark Grey cube appears and no player has this color)
boardgamearena.com/1/troyes?table=89182297
boardgamearena.com/1/troyes?table=89182297
9 ago 2020 17:05 • oninohugo • Bug não foi reproduzido pela equipa de desenvolvimento ainda:
Bug Troyes table 104705628: I'm at 1 point at the end of the penultimate round which is impossible since I have 3 cubes in the cathedral and have claimed 1 event.
9 ago 2020 17:15 • oninohugo • Bug não foi reproduzido pela equipa de desenvolvimento ainda:
13 ago 2020 23:08 • mitcharf • Bug não foi reproduzido pela equipa de desenvolvimento ainda:
oninohugo, I reviewed the log for your game and as far as I can tell your score is correct. Here are all of the log entries where you gain or lose points:
0) Game start (0 vp total)
1) Move 20: Construct cathedral , gain 2 vp (2 vp total)
2) Move 29: Counter event card, gain 2 vp (4 vp total)
3) Move 49: Lose 2 vp from Heresy event card (2 vp total)
4) Move 66: Lose 2 vp from Heresy event card (0 vp total)
5) Move 83: Construct cathedral, gain 1 vp (1 vp total)
Based on that, 1 point was the correct total for you. Or did I miss something in the log?
0) Game start (0 vp total)
1) Move 20: Construct cathedral , gain 2 vp (2 vp total)
2) Move 29: Counter event card, gain 2 vp (4 vp total)
3) Move 49: Lose 2 vp from Heresy event card (2 vp total)
4) Move 66: Lose 2 vp from Heresy event card (0 vp total)
5) Move 83: Construct cathedral, gain 1 vp (1 vp total)
Based on that, 1 point was the correct total for you. Or did I miss something in the log?
13 ago 2020 23:14 • mitcharf • Bug não foi reproduzido pela equipa de desenvolvimento ainda:
parsonii, I reviewed the log for your game. Here are all of the cathedral-related point gains and losses in your game log:
Move 19: parsonii constructs cathedral, gain 1 vp
Move 25: FreakinFred constructs cathedral, gains 1 vp
Move 77: FreakinFred constructs cathedral, gains 1 vp
Move 85/game end: FreakinFred is absent in 1 level, loses 2 vp
Move 85/game end: parsonii is absent in 2 levels, loses 4 vp
Total cathedral vp for parsonii = 1 - 4 = -3
Total cathedral vp for FreakinFred = 1 + 1 - 2 = 0
So I think your totals are correct as well.
Move 19: parsonii constructs cathedral, gain 1 vp
Move 25: FreakinFred constructs cathedral, gains 1 vp
Move 77: FreakinFred constructs cathedral, gains 1 vp
Move 85/game end: FreakinFred is absent in 1 level, loses 2 vp
Move 85/game end: parsonii is absent in 2 levels, loses 4 vp
Total cathedral vp for parsonii = 1 - 4 = -3
Total cathedral vp for FreakinFred = 1 + 1 - 2 = 0
So I think your totals are correct as well.
13 ago 2020 23:23 • mitcharf • Bug não foi reproduzido pela equipa de desenvolvimento ainda:
zoid4, I reviewed the log for your game. On replay, it shows you are the white player. All of your cahtedral-related events in the log are:
Move 47: Construct 2 cubes in cathedral, gain 2 vp
Move 100: Construct 1 cube in cathedral, gain 1 vp
Move 114: Construct 3 cubes in cathedral, gain 3 vp
So that is 6 cubes total. In the replay, at the end of the game I see your 6 white cubes in the cathedral. Since you have at least 1 cube on each level, you did not lose any points at the end of the game from that. So +6 for cathedral points seems correct.
I think the confusion is that the disc in your sector in the middle is beige, and so are your workers, so you expect your cubes to be beige as well.
To make matters moire confusing, the neutral cubes in the cathedral are dark grey, but the neutral meeples in the buildings are light grey (almost white).
In any case, this is definitely a separate issue from what this bug is reporting. I will search to see if there is already a bug open for this color mish-mash. If there is not one already open, I will open one to document that problem.
Move 47: Construct 2 cubes in cathedral, gain 2 vp
Move 100: Construct 1 cube in cathedral, gain 1 vp
Move 114: Construct 3 cubes in cathedral, gain 3 vp
So that is 6 cubes total. In the replay, at the end of the game I see your 6 white cubes in the cathedral. Since you have at least 1 cube on each level, you did not lose any points at the end of the game from that. So +6 for cathedral points seems correct.
I think the confusion is that the disc in your sector in the middle is beige, and so are your workers, so you expect your cubes to be beige as well.
To make matters moire confusing, the neutral cubes in the cathedral are dark grey, but the neutral meeples in the buildings are light grey (almost white).
In any case, this is definitely a separate issue from what this bug is reporting. I will search to see if there is already a bug open for this color mish-mash. If there is not one already open, I will open one to document that problem.
13 ago 2020 23:24 • mitcharf • Bug não foi reproduzido pela equipa de desenvolvimento ainda:
I'm not a BGA developer, but hopefully I have saved them some time here -- as you can see from my previous 3 comments, a review of the game logs does not indicate any problem with cathedral scoring that I can find.
13 ago 2020 23:43 • mitcharf • Bug não foi reproduzido pela equipa de desenvolvimento ainda:
I have opened the following bug on the color confusion that resulted in zoid4's report. I encourage you to vote for it:
boardgamearena.com/bug?id=22589
boardgamearena.com/bug?id=22589
2 dez 2020 14:56 • 0p0 • Bug não foi reproduzido pela equipa de desenvolvimento ainda:
mitcharf. you wrote:
3) Move 49: Lose 2 vp from Heresy event card (2 vp total)
4) Move 66: Lose 2 vp from Heresy event card (0 vp total)
I read in rules that Heresy card should decrease influence points, not victory points.
3) Move 49: Lose 2 vp from Heresy event card (2 vp total)
4) Move 66: Lose 2 vp from Heresy event card (0 vp total)
I read in rules that Heresy card should decrease influence points, not victory points.
2 dez 2020 15:06 • 0p0 • Bug não foi reproduzido pela equipa de desenvolvimento ainda:
I undarstand probably. Player had no influence points and then lost victory points?
25 out 2023 23:45 • MrRahr • Bug não foi reproduzido pela equipa de desenvolvimento ainda:
Same problem at the end of game #431920406 October 2023
Adicione alguma coisa para este relatório
Por favor, adicione aqui qualquer coisa que pareça relevante para a reprodução deste bug ou o entendimento de sua sugestão:
- Outro ID de mesa / ID de jogada
- Carregar em F5 resolveu o problema?
- O problema aparece várias vezes? Sempre? Imprevisivelmente?
- Se tiver uma captura de ecrã/tela deste problema (boa prática), pode usar Imgur.com para carregá-la e copiar/colar o endereço aqui.
