#86291: "Allow peeking in phase B (as an option)"
Sobre o que é este relatório?
O que aconteceu ? Por favor escolha abaixo
O que aconteceu ? Por favor escolha abaixo
Por favor, cheque se já há um report com o mesmo assunto
Se sim, por favor, VOTE para este report. Reports com mais votos recebem PRIORIDADE!
# | Status | Votes | Game | Type | Title | Last update |
---|
Descrição detalhada
-
• Por favor copie e cole a mensagem de erro que aparece na tela, se possível.
First, I'm fully aware that the rule doesn't allow this.
Page 7:
You can take only the top card of a discard pile, and you cannot look through the discard piles.
So we might need clearance from the designer to allow this as an option.
-------------
This being said, looking through comments on BGG, it seems to be a rather common house rule.
More importantly, removing memory elements from a game is a very common adaptation on BGA because of turn-based mode.
You can expect people to remember things in a 30min game that you can't expect them to remember it when playing 1 turn every 2 days...
It pushes people into writing things down or computing the current situation by adding up what's in the log or do a "replay from" etc..
If you can rebuild hidden information via the log or "replay from" then the rule is in a way already broken and we should just display the info so as to put everyone back on the same footing. (Provided that "memory" isn't an quintessential component of the game in which case you probably simply do not allow turn-based mode for that game)
Take for instance what was done for the bags in "Automobiles".
With everything I explained above, I'm not even sure that we need author permission for this. But I fully understand if you feel that you do.
-----------------------
In my opinion, the ideal would be a 3 values option:
- No Peeking allowed
- Peeking allowed
- Peeking allowed in turn-based mode
The point of the 3 option being that it can be set as the chosen option for Arena mode if the gurus want it.
-----
As for the actual implementation, the simplest would probably be that hovering on a discarded card would show all the cards in the stack (from left to right representing cards from bottom to top).
-
• Por favor explique o que queria fazer, o que fez e o que aconteceu
• Qual navegador você está usando?
Google Chrome v102
-
• Por favor copie/cole o texto em inglês em vez de sua língua. Se tiver uma captura de ecrã/tela deste problema (boa prática), pode usar Imgur.com para carregá-la e copiar/colar o endereço aqui.
First, I'm fully aware that the rule doesn't allow this.
Page 7:
You can take only the top card of a discard pile, and you cannot look through the discard piles.
So we might need clearance from the designer to allow this as an option.
-------------
This being said, looking through comments on BGG, it seems to be a rather common house rule.
More importantly, removing memory elements from a game is a very common adaptation on BGA because of turn-based mode.
You can expect people to remember things in a 30min game that you can't expect them to remember it when playing 1 turn every 2 days...
It pushes people into writing things down or computing the current situation by adding up what's in the log or do a "replay from" etc..
If you can rebuild hidden information via the log or "replay from" then the rule is in a way already broken and we should just display the info so as to put everyone back on the same footing. (Provided that "memory" isn't an quintessential component of the game in which case you probably simply do not allow turn-based mode for that game)
Take for instance what was done for the bags in "Automobiles".
With everything I explained above, I'm not even sure that we need author permission for this. But I fully understand if you feel that you do.
-----------------------
In my opinion, the ideal would be a 3 values option:
- No Peeking allowed
- Peeking allowed
- Peeking allowed in turn-based mode
The point of the 3 option being that it can be set as the chosen option for Arena mode if the gurus want it.
-----
As for the actual implementation, the simplest would probably be that hovering on a discarded card would show all the cards in the stack (from left to right representing cards from bottom to top).
-
• Este texto está disponível no sistema de traduções? Se sim, foi traduzido há mais de 24 horas?
• Qual navegador você está usando?
Google Chrome v102
-
• Por favor, explique sua sugestão precisamente e de forma concisa, de forma que fique o mais fácil possível, entender o que você quer dizer.
First, I'm fully aware that the rule doesn't allow this.
Page 7:
You can take only the top card of a discard pile, and you cannot look through the discard piles.
So we might need clearance from the designer to allow this as an option.
-------------
This being said, looking through comments on BGG, it seems to be a rather common house rule.
More importantly, removing memory elements from a game is a very common adaptation on BGA because of turn-based mode.
You can expect people to remember things in a 30min game that you can't expect them to remember it when playing 1 turn every 2 days...
It pushes people into writing things down or computing the current situation by adding up what's in the log or do a "replay from" etc..
If you can rebuild hidden information via the log or "replay from" then the rule is in a way already broken and we should just display the info so as to put everyone back on the same footing. (Provided that "memory" isn't an quintessential component of the game in which case you probably simply do not allow turn-based mode for that game)
Take for instance what was done for the bags in "Automobiles".
With everything I explained above, I'm not even sure that we need author permission for this. But I fully understand if you feel that you do.
-----------------------
In my opinion, the ideal would be a 3 values option:
- No Peeking allowed
- Peeking allowed
- Peeking allowed in turn-based mode
The point of the 3 option being that it can be set as the chosen option for Arena mode if the gurus want it.
-----
As for the actual implementation, the simplest would probably be that hovering on a discarded card would show all the cards in the stack (from left to right representing cards from bottom to top).
• Qual navegador você está usando?
Google Chrome v102
-
• O que estava presente na tela quando você estava bloqueado (tela em branco? Parte da imagem do jogo? Mensagem de erro?)
First, I'm fully aware that the rule doesn't allow this.
Page 7:
You can take only the top card of a discard pile, and you cannot look through the discard piles.
So we might need clearance from the designer to allow this as an option.
-------------
This being said, looking through comments on BGG, it seems to be a rather common house rule.
More importantly, removing memory elements from a game is a very common adaptation on BGA because of turn-based mode.
You can expect people to remember things in a 30min game that you can't expect them to remember it when playing 1 turn every 2 days...
It pushes people into writing things down or computing the current situation by adding up what's in the log or do a "replay from" etc..
If you can rebuild hidden information via the log or "replay from" then the rule is in a way already broken and we should just display the info so as to put everyone back on the same footing. (Provided that "memory" isn't an quintessential component of the game in which case you probably simply do not allow turn-based mode for that game)
Take for instance what was done for the bags in "Automobiles".
With everything I explained above, I'm not even sure that we need author permission for this. But I fully understand if you feel that you do.
-----------------------
In my opinion, the ideal would be a 3 values option:
- No Peeking allowed
- Peeking allowed
- Peeking allowed in turn-based mode
The point of the 3 option being that it can be set as the chosen option for Arena mode if the gurus want it.
-----
As for the actual implementation, the simplest would probably be that hovering on a discarded card would show all the cards in the stack (from left to right representing cards from bottom to top).
• Qual navegador você está usando?
Google Chrome v102
-
• Que parte das regras não foi respeitada pela adaptação do BGA?
First, I'm fully aware that the rule doesn't allow this.
Page 7:
You can take only the top card of a discard pile, and you cannot look through the discard piles.
So we might need clearance from the designer to allow this as an option.
-------------
This being said, looking through comments on BGG, it seems to be a rather common house rule.
More importantly, removing memory elements from a game is a very common adaptation on BGA because of turn-based mode.
You can expect people to remember things in a 30min game that you can't expect them to remember it when playing 1 turn every 2 days...
It pushes people into writing things down or computing the current situation by adding up what's in the log or do a "replay from" etc..
If you can rebuild hidden information via the log or "replay from" then the rule is in a way already broken and we should just display the info so as to put everyone back on the same footing. (Provided that "memory" isn't an quintessential component of the game in which case you probably simply do not allow turn-based mode for that game)
Take for instance what was done for the bags in "Automobiles".
With everything I explained above, I'm not even sure that we need author permission for this. But I fully understand if you feel that you do.
-----------------------
In my opinion, the ideal would be a 3 values option:
- No Peeking allowed
- Peeking allowed
- Peeking allowed in turn-based mode
The point of the 3 option being that it can be set as the chosen option for Arena mode if the gurus want it.
-----
As for the actual implementation, the simplest would probably be that hovering on a discarded card would show all the cards in the stack (from left to right representing cards from bottom to top).
-
• A violação de regras está visível na revisão do jogo? Se sim, em que número de jogada?
• Qual navegador você está usando?
Google Chrome v102
-
• Qual era a ação de jogo que queria fazer?
First, I'm fully aware that the rule doesn't allow this.
Page 7:
You can take only the top card of a discard pile, and you cannot look through the discard piles.
So we might need clearance from the designer to allow this as an option.
-------------
This being said, looking through comments on BGG, it seems to be a rather common house rule.
More importantly, removing memory elements from a game is a very common adaptation on BGA because of turn-based mode.
You can expect people to remember things in a 30min game that you can't expect them to remember it when playing 1 turn every 2 days...
It pushes people into writing things down or computing the current situation by adding up what's in the log or do a "replay from" etc..
If you can rebuild hidden information via the log or "replay from" then the rule is in a way already broken and we should just display the info so as to put everyone back on the same footing. (Provided that "memory" isn't an quintessential component of the game in which case you probably simply do not allow turn-based mode for that game)
Take for instance what was done for the bags in "Automobiles".
With everything I explained above, I'm not even sure that we need author permission for this. But I fully understand if you feel that you do.
-----------------------
In my opinion, the ideal would be a 3 values option:
- No Peeking allowed
- Peeking allowed
- Peeking allowed in turn-based mode
The point of the 3 option being that it can be set as the chosen option for Arena mode if the gurus want it.
-----
As for the actual implementation, the simplest would probably be that hovering on a discarded card would show all the cards in the stack (from left to right representing cards from bottom to top).
-
• O que você tentou fazer para provocar esta ação de jogo?
-
• O que aconteceu quando tentou fazer isto(mensagem de erro, mensagem na barra de estado do jogo)?
• Qual navegador você está usando?
Google Chrome v102
-
• Em que passo do jogo ocorre o problema(qual era a instrução corrente do jogo)?
First, I'm fully aware that the rule doesn't allow this.
Page 7:
You can take only the top card of a discard pile, and you cannot look through the discard piles.
So we might need clearance from the designer to allow this as an option.
-------------
This being said, looking through comments on BGG, it seems to be a rather common house rule.
More importantly, removing memory elements from a game is a very common adaptation on BGA because of turn-based mode.
You can expect people to remember things in a 30min game that you can't expect them to remember it when playing 1 turn every 2 days...
It pushes people into writing things down or computing the current situation by adding up what's in the log or do a "replay from" etc..
If you can rebuild hidden information via the log or "replay from" then the rule is in a way already broken and we should just display the info so as to put everyone back on the same footing. (Provided that "memory" isn't an quintessential component of the game in which case you probably simply do not allow turn-based mode for that game)
Take for instance what was done for the bags in "Automobiles".
With everything I explained above, I'm not even sure that we need author permission for this. But I fully understand if you feel that you do.
-----------------------
In my opinion, the ideal would be a 3 values option:
- No Peeking allowed
- Peeking allowed
- Peeking allowed in turn-based mode
The point of the 3 option being that it can be set as the chosen option for Arena mode if the gurus want it.
-----
As for the actual implementation, the simplest would probably be that hovering on a discarded card would show all the cards in the stack (from left to right representing cards from bottom to top).
-
• O que aconteceu quando tentou fazer essa ação de jogo (mensagem de erro, mensagem na barra de estado do jogo)?
• Qual navegador você está usando?
Google Chrome v102
-
• Por favor descreva o problema de visualização. Se tiver uma captura de ecrã/tela deste problema (boa prática), pode usar Imgur.com para carregá-la e copiar/colar o endereço aqui.
First, I'm fully aware that the rule doesn't allow this.
Page 7:
You can take only the top card of a discard pile, and you cannot look through the discard piles.
So we might need clearance from the designer to allow this as an option.
-------------
This being said, looking through comments on BGG, it seems to be a rather common house rule.
More importantly, removing memory elements from a game is a very common adaptation on BGA because of turn-based mode.
You can expect people to remember things in a 30min game that you can't expect them to remember it when playing 1 turn every 2 days...
It pushes people into writing things down or computing the current situation by adding up what's in the log or do a "replay from" etc..
If you can rebuild hidden information via the log or "replay from" then the rule is in a way already broken and we should just display the info so as to put everyone back on the same footing. (Provided that "memory" isn't an quintessential component of the game in which case you probably simply do not allow turn-based mode for that game)
Take for instance what was done for the bags in "Automobiles".
With everything I explained above, I'm not even sure that we need author permission for this. But I fully understand if you feel that you do.
-----------------------
In my opinion, the ideal would be a 3 values option:
- No Peeking allowed
- Peeking allowed
- Peeking allowed in turn-based mode
The point of the 3 option being that it can be set as the chosen option for Arena mode if the gurus want it.
-----
As for the actual implementation, the simplest would probably be that hovering on a discarded card would show all the cards in the stack (from left to right representing cards from bottom to top).
• Qual navegador você está usando?
Google Chrome v102
-
• Por favor copie/cole o texto em inglês em vez de sua língua. Se tiver uma captura de ecrã/tela deste problema (boa prática), pode usar Imgur.com para carregá-la e copiar/colar o endereço aqui.
First, I'm fully aware that the rule doesn't allow this.
Page 7:
You can take only the top card of a discard pile, and you cannot look through the discard piles.
So we might need clearance from the designer to allow this as an option.
-------------
This being said, looking through comments on BGG, it seems to be a rather common house rule.
More importantly, removing memory elements from a game is a very common adaptation on BGA because of turn-based mode.
You can expect people to remember things in a 30min game that you can't expect them to remember it when playing 1 turn every 2 days...
It pushes people into writing things down or computing the current situation by adding up what's in the log or do a "replay from" etc..
If you can rebuild hidden information via the log or "replay from" then the rule is in a way already broken and we should just display the info so as to put everyone back on the same footing. (Provided that "memory" isn't an quintessential component of the game in which case you probably simply do not allow turn-based mode for that game)
Take for instance what was done for the bags in "Automobiles".
With everything I explained above, I'm not even sure that we need author permission for this. But I fully understand if you feel that you do.
-----------------------
In my opinion, the ideal would be a 3 values option:
- No Peeking allowed
- Peeking allowed
- Peeking allowed in turn-based mode
The point of the 3 option being that it can be set as the chosen option for Arena mode if the gurus want it.
-----
As for the actual implementation, the simplest would probably be that hovering on a discarded card would show all the cards in the stack (from left to right representing cards from bottom to top).
-
• Este texto está disponível no sistema de traduções? Se sim, foi traduzido há mais de 24 horas?
• Qual navegador você está usando?
Google Chrome v102
-
• Por favor, explique sua sugestão precisamente e de forma concisa, de forma que fique o mais fácil possível, entender o que você quer dizer.
First, I'm fully aware that the rule doesn't allow this.
Page 7:
You can take only the top card of a discard pile, and you cannot look through the discard piles.
So we might need clearance from the designer to allow this as an option.
-------------
This being said, looking through comments on BGG, it seems to be a rather common house rule.
More importantly, removing memory elements from a game is a very common adaptation on BGA because of turn-based mode.
You can expect people to remember things in a 30min game that you can't expect them to remember it when playing 1 turn every 2 days...
It pushes people into writing things down or computing the current situation by adding up what's in the log or do a "replay from" etc..
If you can rebuild hidden information via the log or "replay from" then the rule is in a way already broken and we should just display the info so as to put everyone back on the same footing. (Provided that "memory" isn't an quintessential component of the game in which case you probably simply do not allow turn-based mode for that game)
Take for instance what was done for the bags in "Automobiles".
With everything I explained above, I'm not even sure that we need author permission for this. But I fully understand if you feel that you do.
-----------------------
In my opinion, the ideal would be a 3 values option:
- No Peeking allowed
- Peeking allowed
- Peeking allowed in turn-based mode
The point of the 3 option being that it can be set as the chosen option for Arena mode if the gurus want it.
-----
As for the actual implementation, the simplest would probably be that hovering on a discarded card would show all the cards in the stack (from left to right representing cards from bottom to top).
• Qual navegador você está usando?
Google Chrome v102
Histórico do relatório
Adicione alguma coisa para este relatório
- Outro ID de mesa / ID de jogada
- Carregar em F5 resolveu o problema?
- O problema aparece várias vezes? Sempre? Imprevisivelmente?
- Se tiver uma captura de ecrã/tela deste problema (boa prática), pode usar Imgur.com para carregá-la e copiar/colar o endereço aqui.